On July 29, 2026, a two-bedroom condo at 5 Main Street in Rosemary Beach closed for $1,820,000. It has 785 square feet, so the buyer paid about $2,318 a foot. This month, a six-bedroom house at 179 E Kingston Road sold for $4,490,000. It has 6,000 square feet and guest quarters over a detached garage, which works out to about $748 a foot. The house cost about two and a half times as much in total. Per foot, the condo cost three times as much.
Both sales are in the same town, and both buyers made sensible choices. Price per square foot is the number buyers lean on most when they compare 30A neighborhoods. Inside Rosemary Beach, it mostly tells you where a property sits and how its space is split. It says much less about the quality of the home.
The Averages Run the Other Way
In local MLS data for July through September 2026, Rosemary Beach houses averaged $1,281 a square foot, up 6% from the same quarter in 2025. Condos in Rosemary Beach averaged $1,669 a foot, up 22%. Over that quarter, condos sold in 65 days on average and houses in 109.
Usually a buyer expects a condo to be the cheaper way into a town. In Rosemary that quarter, the condo foot cost about $388 more, and condos sold faster. Eleven houses closed in the quarter, up from three in the same months of 2025, and houses had about six months of supply.
The same data puts Rosemary's quarterly house average at $1,281 a foot. Alys Beach averaged $2,038, Seaside $1,543 and WaterColor $1,054. If you're comparing those towns, our side-by-side look at Alys Beach and other 30A enclaves covers the differences beyond price.
One Street, One Price, Two Kinds of Property
Town Hall Road is the cleanest test. In February 2026, a house at 36 Town Hall Road sold for $3,400,000. It is south of 30A and has 2,056 square feet, or about $1,654 a foot. In June, two condos down the street in The Orleans at 74 Town Hall Road, also south of 30A with Gulf views, closed within four days of each other. Unit 3A sold for $2,700,000 for 1,654 square feet, about $1,632 a foot. Unit 3B sold for $2,882,500 for 1,790 square feet, about $1,610 a foot.
So a detached house and two condos on the same street sold within about $45 a foot of each other. A condo on North Barrett Square in the town center, 104 N Barrett Square #3B, closed in January at about $1,658 a foot. Close to the town center and south of the highway, buyers priced the foot at roughly the same level whether it came as a house or a condo.
This follows from the town plan. Duany Plater-Zyberk & Company designed Rosemary Beach, which was founded in 1995 with more than 400 home sites around a mixed-use town center. County Road 30A runs through the middle of town. The walk to the Gulf and the walk to the shops are what buyers pay for here, and the square footage comes with them.
The 2026 Sales, Sorted by Price per Foot
The closed sales below cover January through November 2026. Each price per foot is the sale price divided by the recorded square footage. They're a selection of examples, not every sale in town, and they're sorted from highest to lowest per foot.
| Property | Type | What sets it apart | Closed | Price | Sq ft | About per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Atwoods Court | House | Gulf-front | Mar 2026 | $7,835,000 | 2,465 | $3,179 |
| 5 Main Street #2C | Condo | Town center | Jul 2026 | $1,820,000 | 785 | $2,318 |
| 104 N Barrett Square #2B | Condo | North Barrett Square | Sep 2026 | $2,245,000 | 1,232 | $1,822 |
| 78 N Barrett Square #6 | Condo | North Barrett Square | Sep 2026 | $2,550,000 | 1,442 | $1,768 |
| 104 N Barrett Square #3B | Condo | North Barrett Square | Jan 2026 | $2,275,000 | 1,372 | $1,658 |
| 36 Town Hall Road | House | South of 30A | Feb 2026 | $3,400,000 | 2,056 | $1,654 |
| 74 Town Hall Road #3A | Condo | The Orleans, Gulf view | Jun 2026 | $2,700,000 | 1,654 | $1,632 |
| 74 Town Hall Road #3B | Condo | The Orleans, Gulf view | Jun 2026 | $2,882,500 | 1,790 | $1,610 |
| 171 Round Road | House | Two-building compound | May 2026 | $6,550,000 | 4,100 | $1,598 |
| 15 St. Augustine Street #5302 15F | Condo | 957 sq ft unit | Feb 2026 | $1,400,000 | 957 | $1,463 |
| 27 St. Augustine Street #6201 | Condo | 957 sq ft unit | Feb 2026 | $1,240,000 | 957 | $1,296 |
| 132 E Kingston Road | House | Carriage house | Aug 2026 | $3,910,000 | 3,042 | $1,285 |
| 107 Wiggle Lane | House | Main house plus carriage house | Oct 2026 | $3,100,000 | 2,699 | $1,149 |
| 87 Bridgetown Avenue | House | Carriage house over garage | Sep 2026 | $3,800,000 | 4,380 | $868 |
| 179 E Kingston Road | House | Guest quarters over garage | Nov 2026 | $4,490,000 | 6,000 | $748 |
Two things set the top of the table. The single Gulf-front house is first, at about $3,179 a foot. Next come the small units at the town center. Barrett Square is Rosemary's shopping and dining core, and its residential buildings include The Georgetown, The Lofts at Barrett Square, Lofts West, Antigua, Tabby Lofts and Barrett Place. Most of them have balconies over the square. At 785 square feet, the Main Street unit spread a $1.82 million price across very little floor area, so its per-foot figure reflects the address more than the size.
Even units with the same floor area don't share a single price per foot. The two 957-square-foot units on St. Augustine Street sold in February, eight days apart, at $1,463 and $1,296 a foot. They were the same size and sold in the same month, yet $167 a foot apart, a gap that no townwide average would show.
The Carriage House Pulls the Number Down
The bottom of the table is mostly houses with a second building. 87 Bridgetown Avenue has a carriage house over a detached garage and sold in September for about $868 a foot. 179 E Kingston Road has guest quarters in the same arrangement and came in at about $748. 107 Wiggle Lane has a two-bedroom carriage house behind a four-bedroom main house and closed in October at about $1,149.
Rosemary lots are narrow and the houses sit close together. A carriage house adds bedrooms and square footage to a lot without changing how far it is from the beach or the town center. That makes the per-foot figure smaller, even though these were some of the larger total prices of the year. A buyer who screens Rosemary listings by price per foot will see these homes as bargains next to a Barrett Square loft. That comparison doesn't hold. A carriage-house lot should be compared only with other lots that have a second structure. Putting the two types in one set of comparables throws the result off.
These homes also took longer to sell. The sold records show price reductions on four of the larger houses. The reductions were $275,000 at 132 E Kingston Road, $350,000 at 107 Wiggle Lane, $595,000 at 87 Bridgetown Avenue and $949,000 at 171 Round Road. The condos closed much nearer their asking prices. 104 N Barrett Square #3B listed at $2,300,000 and sold for $2,275,000, and 78 N Barrett Square #6 sold for $90,000 under its $2,640,000 asking price. This matches the quarterly figures of 65 days on market for condos and 109 for houses. Buyers paid more per foot for less space at the town center and decided quickly. The bigger compounds sold after negotiation.
What This Means for a Mid-Season Search
In mid-October, Rosemary Beach had 13 single-family homes for sale, asking $2.95 million to $8.1 million, and 11 condos and townhomes asking $1.25 million to $3.389 million. Every one of those single-family listings was built between 1998 and 2015. Since no house was newer than about eleven years old, renovation and finish level separate one listing from another as much as build year does.
For a buyer, the practical step is to pick the position before the property type. Decide first where you want to be: Gulf-front, south of 30A within a few blocks of Town Hall Road, on Barrett Square, or on a quieter street with room for a carriage house. Within that position, price per foot is a fair comparison. Across positions, the 2026 sales show it can mislead a buyer by more than $2,000 a foot.
The quarterly numbers come from a small base. With only eleven house sales in a quarter, one Gulf-front closing can move the average. The street-level pattern above comes from individual sales, so it doesn't depend on that average. If you're weighing a Barrett Square condo against a house, the association structure matters too. Our guide to HOA and condo associations in Rosemary Beach covers how dues and coverage differ, and the Rosemary Beach neighborhood page has current listings.
Quick Answers
Why did Rosemary Beach condos average more per square foot than houses in Q3 2026? Most of the condos in the 2026 sales are small units at the town center or south of 30A. Several of the houses spread their price across carriage houses and big footprints. From July through September 2026, condos averaged $1,669 a foot and houses $1,281.
Is a carriage-house home in Rosemary Beach a better value per foot? It has more square feet for its location. The fair test is to compare it with other carriage-house lots in a similar position, not with a condo or a single-structure house.
Where did the highest per-foot sale of 2026 happen? In the sales above, it was 26 Atwoods Court, a Gulf-front house that closed in March 2026 for $7,835,000, about $3,179 a foot.
If you're deciding between a Barrett Square condo and a house south of 30A, or wondering how a carriage house changes the value of the lot you're looking at, Anderson Group 30A can compare the closed sales for that exact position, street by street. Get your custom 30A market report, or start with a valuation of the Rosemary Beach property you already own.